Should You Resurface Your Asphalt Driveway?

Asphalt driveways can wear down over time from poor initial installation, Canadian weather and general use. Sometimes, resurfacing can extend their life and make them look fresh again, but resurfacing isn't always the best choice!

Here are some key things to consider to help you decide if resurfacing or a full driveway replacement will give you better results.

1. Driveway Size: Is It Truly Cost Effective?

For driveways under 1,000 square feet, resurfacing is often not worth it. Small driveways can often end up costing almost as much to resurface as to fully replace due to the materials, equiptment and labor required. For smaller spaces, investing in a full replacement will typically give you a longer-lasting, higher-quality result.

Quick Tip:
If your driveway is on the smaller side, ask a paving professional if replacement might be a better investment.

2. Available Space for an Overlay: Is There Enough Room?

For a resurfacing job to work, there needs to be enough room for an extra layer of asphalt on top of the existing. Driveways often settle down in front of garages over time, providing the required 2-3 inches of space

for a new layer. But it’s essential that this depth is consistent along the whole driveway, including the curb area. If there’s not enough space, the overlay may end up too thin at the edge, which means it won’t hold up as well over time.

Quick Tip:
Check the thickness needed at both the garage and curb. If it won’t be uniform, resurfacing may not be the best choice.

3. Driveway Condition: How Damaged Is the Surface?

One of the most important factors in deciding whether to resurface is the current condition of the asphalt. Resurfacing is best for driveways with only minor cracks or surface issues. If the driveway is mostly intact with only a few cracks and no “alligatoring” (a pattern of deep cracks that look like alligator skin), resurfacing could work well.

However, if there are large, deep cracks or major areas of damage, resurfacing is unlikely to hold up. In these cases, a full replacement is the smarter, long-term choice.

Quick Tip:
If you notice only a few surface-level cracks, resurfacing may be enough to extend the life of your driveway. But if there’s widespread cracking, replacement will likely give you better results.

4. Personal Expectations: Can You Handle Future Cracks?

Resurfacing can freshen up the look of a driveway and help it last longer, but it won’t erase all signs of aging. Cracks will likely reappear over time, especially in areas where they were before. While resurfacing does extend the driveway's life, it’s important to know that it won’t give you a completely “new” driveway.

If you’re okay with a few future cracks and want a budget-friendly way to extend your driveway's life, resurfacing could be a good option. But if you want a smooth, crack-free surface that will stay that way for years to come, a full replacement will provide a more satisfying result.

For example, we often provide resurfacing services for real estate agents who are looking to increase the curb appeal of a property but don't value the longest lasting job.

Quick Tip:
If you’re set on a perfectly smooth finish, go for a replacement. But if you just need to extend the life and improve the look, resurfacing may be a reasonable solution.

Conclusion

Deciding between resurfacing and replacing your asphalt driveway depends on the size, available space, current condition, and your expectations. Resurfacing can be an excellent option for driveways that are in generally good shape and have enough space for a new layer. But if there’s extensive damage or you’re hoping for a “like new” finish, a full replacement may be a better long-term investment.

When in doubt, consult a paving professional. They can assess your driveway’s specific needs and recommend the best solution for a durable and attractive surface. Whether you choose resurfacing or replacement, knowing what to expect can help you make the best choice for your driveway.